katie darling, you seem sweet and all, but in that marathon pic, it's called a bra and under-eye concealer! i hope you and your family are happy together, but I'm all for NICOLE!

KATIE IS WAY MORE CUTER AND SEXYER , NICOLE LOOKS LIKE AN ALIEN , SHE HAD WAY TOO MUCH BOTOX INJECTET IN HER , KATIE IS A BETTER WOMAN SHE LOVES THOSE ADOPTED KIDS LIKE IF THEY WERE HERS , NICOLE U CAN"T EVEN WIPE KAIE ASS FOR GODS SAKE , SHE IS SO PHONIE. SHE USES WAY TOO MUCH COKE HER EYES ARE ALWAYS TEARY.

Depite most of you, I think Katie should win. She`s succesful, beautiful, a wonderful mother. Nicole seems kindof snotty sometimes(only from what i can tell in the pictures). I think Katie has awider sense o style and haircuts. Anyway,to sum th all up Katie sould win.

I think nicole is classy but also a very high maintenance woman In my opinion I think Katie is a much better person as she is more of a Real Person and not as fake and self centered as nicole. Just hope one day Katie will be given the chance to make more of her self like the other women tom had... Its almost imposible to compare the to as nicole is older and had time to make a name for herself where as Katie hasn't had that chance yet. Hopefully Katie will get the media coverage after the devorce like nicolle did to boost her career. Love ya Katie!!!! your an awesome role model for our children.

Well, first off I can't image what chemicals were needed for two wonderful women to marry a nut-job like T>C., however history has shown that even psycho?s like T.C. can get a good women once in a while and keep them with religious brain washing techniques. Anyway, before either one of them met Tom, they were both incredible young women, however it is obvious that Nicole had weathered the T-STorm allot better then current zombie Katie. I really feel bad for her when i see her in pictures. It is so obvious that the smiles are fake and she is putting up a show. Nicole on the other hand has always proven to be a true lady in every sense of the word and that is how she pushed through a creepy marriage with psycho man T.C. I'm betting that DNA scans and med records will show one day that Tom could not naturally get Katie preggie and he had to purchase the other half from a male donor somewhere. What woman would want him touching her? I just don't see it.

scientology sucks ... thats all I know Katie is way better looking ... but cmon ... scientology? wow

Katie looks much more real and natural. She expresses softness, generosity, youth. Nicole is not so goodlooking and appears to be more superficial.

I think they just both get over the past and move on with there lives. I think if Tom wanted to be with one more than the other; he would be so get over the tears and heartbreak and grow up.

Look at old pictures of Nicole Kidman....,hmmm,it looks like perhaps she has had a nose job! So I would have to vote for Katie Holmes. REAL, NATURAL beauty! Nicole Kidman is a striking woman but not all natural!!

These women are complete strangers to you all and your flowery comments about their subtle personality quirks lower the standards of the world and debase us all. Learn to play the tinwhistle and never come to this site again.

Nicole all the way. She oozes elegance and class. She is one of hollywood's class acts and a good role model. Nicole is independant and has her own beliefs and values and she truly is a good person. She has never once said a bad thing about her ex even when she was going through all that pain. Katie has lost her true sense of self.

I totally love Katie Holmes she is prettier and doesnt look like she's avoiding the sun like she's allergic to the sun.nicole gives me the creeps with her extra white skin and blood red lips.katie is a lil too thin now and needs to go back to the curvey girl she was before.love ya katie

I am not sure why were are putting these two beautiful intelligent women up against one another. I guess you could say their downfall is Tom Cruise, the too controlling scienctologist who attempts to put his wives in their place by asking them to be a certain way. He is way to controlling and eventually Katie will learn that she is way better than that and move onto someone who lets her be who she wants to be. Look at Nicole, she has moved on and is better for it. Stronger and happier.... Down the road will be comparing another new person against Katie and Nicole, Tom Cruise is arrogant and does not realize the beauties that he has had. I use to be a Tom Cruise fan, but I also have become smarter....

Katie is gorgeous. Nicole looks like an albino. Career and talent wise, yes, Nicole takes the cake. If we are simply judging looks, Katie is a much more attractive woman. Now lets not get into who has better taste in men.... crazies, alcoholics... too much to discuss!

I think Katie is a want to be Nicole. Nicole is an amazing actress and well kept. I think Katie is pursing her daughter more than she is her own acting role. Just preference and I cannot stand Katie Holmes! Cruise is too good for her.. shes in it for the money!

Nicole is not as pretty as she once was, her features look sharper and her eyes always appear bloodshot, she looked way better when she was younger, she looks like she has over done cosmetic S. Katie looks not happy as she once looked, they both are equal to me, Tom come first and the ladies are puppets.

Why are her ( Nicole's ) eyes always blood shot?

Katie is gorgeous, much more of a natural all-American beauty. Good clean healthy looks

Nothing against either female, but he left a woman and married a girl.

To each his/her own, but for me it would be Katie all the way! I really don't get the Nicole Kidman thing. The only picture I find her the least bit attractive is #18, and even that's no prize. There are a couple where she actually looks very unattractive. As for her personality, those of us who don't actually know her have no way of saying. But from her interviews, I find her so phony that I actually wonder whether anyone, including her "friends," actually knows her.

100% Nicole, she is truly a beautiful woman inside and out. Katie is only now becoming popular because of who she is married to. Let's be honest that is also CREEPY and sick. Katie could have done alot better for herself. I guess she thinks marrying Tom is what helps jump start a career. Oh well, guess again. Nicole is able to be the whole package, she did not need Tom to help her at all. She is able to hold her head up high and continue on. Married a dwon to earth guy and have a beautiful baby. WAY TO GO NICOLE :)

Nicole is creepy looking. She's never been pretty, just too strange looking. Her eyes always look bloodshot, and she's so pale she looks perpetually sick. Katie is young, fun, and very pretty. She could have married SO much better than lunatic-sci.fi worshipping-controlling man.

so many of you are obviously gossip and tabloid junkies. what on earth are you seeing in the pictures of katie (or nicole even) which could give you ANY insight into their lives with tom? and speaking of tom, do any of you have ANY knowledge of the man that's NOT printed in trashy magazines who pay thier reporters to create intrigue and BS? no one seems to remember reports of tom saving drowning kids' lives or donating tons of money to strangers so their daughter could get much needed surgery... come on people. tom jumps on a couch and he's insane? that's preposterous. katie looks great in a LOT of these pics. so does nicole. they're going to be their own people and lead their own lives and you should keep your uneducated opinions to yourselves. p.s. tom's faith is about helping people who WANT help in improving the different conditions in their lives. there is no brainwashing. PSYCHS created brainwashing and scn. opposes PSYCH practices. don't be so frikkin' narrow-minded.